Istanbul: Competitions Cancelled
The 34th annual Istanbul Film Festival cancelled all of its film competitions at the behest of the various juries, given the extraordinary circumstances at the film festival this year. The festival was forced to withdraw a programmed screening of a Kurdish documentary, “Bakur” (North, Çayan Demirel and Ertugrul Mavioglu, 2015) from the festival, which resulted in all of the domestic competition films except for two being pulled from the festival by the filmmakers.
Filmmakers and Film Critics from Turkey had issued a press release yesterday condemning the decision to censor the film “North” at the Istanbul Film Festival. The signatories of the press statement included most of the filmmakers from Turkey with films in this year’s festival, and they showed a united front by pulling their films from the festival in solidarity with “North”. The festival announced that it was being forced to pull the film from its screening program on the day it was meant to show (12 April 2015), revealing that the Ministry of Culture had arbitrarily decided to enforce an edict requiring domestic film productions to have a exhibition certificate (Eser Isletme Belgesi in Turkish) to show in a cinema. While this edict has been in effect since 2004 it has not been consistently enforced for the festival, and is clearly being trotted out particularly for this film. Most documentary filmmakers in Turkey, including those who made “North”, refuse to apply for the exhibition certificate, rejecting it as a precondition for festival screenings. Yet in announcing the cancellation of the “North” screening, the festival said that they will not screen any Turkish film which does not have exhibition certificate, thus in one stroke rationalizing the festival’s approach, while perhaps unintentionally doing the bidding of the Ministry.
The film, a feature length documentary by accomplished Kurdish filmmaker Demirel, follows the movements of PKK soldiers in the mountains of Turkish Kurdistan (a region also known as Northern Kurdistan, which is why the film is called “Bakur”, North in Kurdish) at a time when there is a rapprochement and ongoing peace process between the leaders of the PKK and the Turkish Government. The film gives an intimate and sympathetic portrait of the life and beliefs of the guerrillas, who have been long battling against the Turkish military. The film was shot during the ceasefire in 2013 and 2014, a rare opportunity to gain insight into the motivations that drove these people out of their villages and cities and into the mountains to take up arms. Unfortunately, Demirel has not been involved in this process, as he suffered a serious heart attack in March and has been hospitalized in intensive care ever since. His wife and the producer of the film, Ayse Çetinbas, along with Ertugrul Mavioglu was at the initial press conference.
The festival had agreed to show the film months ago and the program was publicized widely, though the Ministry of Culture chose not to act until the day of the screening, practically ensuring that protests against the censorship would only come after the fact. This is not the first time censorship has come via the authorities to festival’s in Turkey. For example, a previous film of Demirel’s, “38” (2006), about the 1938 massacre in Dersim, faced a very similar situation at the Munzur festival in Dersim. However the same film was shown in Antalya’s Altin Portakal festival the very next year, with no certificate required; evidence that the demand for the certificate is in all cases politically motivated.
The festival held a press conference today (April 13, 2015) to clarify their position, in part to deflect criticism that was being directed at them. Azize Tan, director of the festival, made it clear that it was due to the direct pressure from the Ministry of Culture demanding this document that they have not required for any of the other festival films, that led to the withdrawal of “North” from the festival. The Ministry of Culture, in a rare move, publicly denied the claims made by the festival and placed the responsibility squarely back with the festival, while claiming that the film in question is “PKK propaganda”, thus any screening of which risk claims of supporting “terrorism”. While such scare tactics may help to sway public opinion, the film community here in Istanbul seems to recognize the divide and rule tactic for what it is and their solidarity has shown no signs of diminishing.
The festival stands with the filmmakers and film community in decrying this blatant act of censorship. Many here hope that this case can be turned into an opportunity to organize against such arbitrary abuses of power. As Tan stated at the press conference, “I hope that this situation converts into an opportunity that brings film industry together to change this regulation. In order to overcome the problems in the industry, I think that a new film regulation should be enacted and it should secure the freedom to screen films at the festival without any problems.”
Turkish and Kurdish filmmakers, as well as film industry professionals are maintaining a united front. To date, more than twenty filmmakers have withdrawn their films from this year’s festival and the pressure is mounting. What will result is as of yet unclear.
For updated information about this unfolding situation, please visit:
(Written with the input of Enis Köstepen, Firat Yücel, Senem Aytaç, Melis Behlil and Banu Karaca)
13 April 2015
Alisa Lebow is a filmmaker and film scholar who teaches film studies at University of Sussex, in England. She serves on the annual selection committee for domestic documentaries for the Istanbul Film Festival. She can be reached at
Berlinale 2021 – The Critics Prizes
PÖFF goes online
FIPRESCI Jury at 71st Berlinale
FIPRESCI 96 Platinum Award to Terry Gilliam and Cristi Puiu
American Critics Attack "Variety"
Critics Week Berlin 2021
Critics Awards 2020
European Film Awards: The Winners
Eva Zaoralová Honored
Indictment for "Cuties"
Berlin 2021 – Conference on Film Criticism
European Discovery 2020, Nominations
Appeal of the Directorate of the Minsk IFF Listapad
Warsaw Critics Project 2020
FIPRESCI Honors Ken Loach
Berlinale Talent Press 2021
Ronald Bergan 1937 – 2020
Controversy at the Cairo International Film Festival
Peter van Bueren, 1942 – 2020
Nelson Hoineff 1948 - 2019
Siegfried Kracauer Prize 2019
Six Debut Films Nominated for the European Film Awards 2019
Rotterdam Young Film Critics Traineeship