Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

A professora de francês — The Limits of Hospitality

A professora de francês — The Limits of Hospitality

Colombian film critic Juan Carlos Lemus Polanía examines Ricardo Alves Jr.’s A professora de francês, exploring how hospitality becomes coercion, religious authority polices sexuality, and the boundaries between gratitude and critical independence are tested at the Mar del Plata International Film Festival.

Small lights thread the darkness of Belo Horizonte. Cars seen from above, beneath fuchsia opening credits. Then the ordinary business of a job interview. Graça (Grace Passô) wants to teach French, but no position is secured. This is how Ricardo Alves Jr.’s A professora de francês (2026) begins. When the neighbours, a family she has known for years, call about her ailing father, she goes to see him. She lives elsewhere with her partner, Clara (Jehnny Beth), and thanks them for looking after him. They urge her to stay. Nothing in their insistence sounds like a threat.

A low wall separates the two houses. From an upper courtyard, Graça watches Tomás (Pedro Goifman) pouring water over himself. He returns her gaze. The exchange is curious, sensual. Their eyes cross a boundary their bodies still respect.

The neighbours ask why Graça refuses invitations and why she never brings a boyfriend home. Clara becomes her ‘friend’. They enter without knocking and know more than they should about her private life. Each intrusion can pass for concern. But the neighbours are not Graça’s hosts. They have cared for her father, not offered her a home, yet behave as though her gratitude has given them a key.

An evangelical prayer gathering for her father’s recovery introduces another shift. Repeated sounds draw the worshippers into a single rhythm. The camera dwells on faces and bodies until separate people begin to resemble a single presence. Later, when Clara arrives to collect Graça, everyone stares at the two women. The prayer has lost its voice, but not its unanimity.

Repetition returns in Graça’s French lessons. At her earlier job interview, she had sought work on her own terms. Now the neighbours have found her a place to teach and recruited the pupils. The classroom retains the familiar structure of a language lesson, but the sentences repeated by the students increasingly question their teacher’s sexuality. The lesson turns upon the woman conducting it. Tomás, meanwhile, speaks fluent French, claiming a divine gift for languages that he intends to use to spread the gospel.

The same Tomás whose glance across the courtyard seemed so unguarded becomes a leading figure in the religious community. Tenório (Rômulo Braga), a candidate for local office, appears to be the man with whom the neighbours would like to pair Graça. Nothing is openly proposed. Religious authority reaches towards political power through the attempted correction of a woman’s sexuality. These people may genuinely believe they are saving her. Their conviction does not make them less frightening. It makes their interference harder to resist.

Her father dies; Graça closes his eyes. As the intrusions escalate, the neighbours murder Clara in front of her. Then they knock down the dividing wall and occupy the house. The camera stays close to the demolition. The noise of drills fills the air while Graça stands almost motionless, unable to speak. The wall had allowed two people to exchange a glance while keeping their households apart. Its destruction erases that boundary. Passô’s stillness conveys shock hardening into something like possession, as though the family that took over her home has also taken over her will. By then, we want that stillness broken. When it breaks, it does so without warning, staged with care only in the moment of the act.

Graça strikes back. We see her prepare a fire, followed by an explosion and smoke. Almost the entire family dies, off-screen. She rescues their baby from the blaze she started and takes it with her. The neighbours killed Clara and took over Graça’s life; Graça kills the child’s family and assumes control of its future. The acts are not equivalent. Yet the resemblance casts a shadow over her victory.

The unseen deaths are not the problem. Withholding burning bodies may deny us the spectacle of punishment. The trouble lies elsewhere. Having shown how protection becomes possession, the film scarcely examines the violence beneath Graça’s new role as the child’s guardian. Behind her, smoke and a blurred background obscure the destruction. Whether Graça acts as herself or as something the neighbours have made of her, the film barely asks what becomes of the child. Alves Jr. has constructed a disturbing contradiction and then let the escape carry it away.

The film’s account of how a community takes possession of a life has a political history. At Mar del Plata, Alves Jr. traced the project to his horror at hearing Jair Bolsonaro, then a federal deputy, dedicate his 2016 impeachment vote against Dilma Rousseff to the colonel who had commanded a São Paulo torture centre, hailing him as “the dread of Dilma Rousseff”. Yet the film needs no explanation from its director to disclose its politics. They are already there, in the rearrangement of domestic space, the appropriation of work, the policing of desire.

At the festival press conference, co-artistic director Jorge Stamadianos presented the film as an exploration of syncretism between Afro-Brazilian religions and evangelical Christianity. When Alves Jr. explained its political origins, Stamadianos thanked him for the information. The exchange exposed a limitation in the festival’s framing of the film. Religious traditions had been named; the machinery through which faith becomes authority remained largely unspoken. That gap matters at a festival whose International Competition ought to make its artistic criteria legible.

Within that competition, A professora de francês stood out without being exceptional. Its horror score rarely escapes convention, yet its wall, collective gaze and language lessons make coercion tangible. In Kindik, a father who abandoned his son appears almost from nowhere to explain that he is still his father. A declaration is asked to perform the work of a relationship the film has failed to develop. In Vigilante, the music sounds the alarm at danger or signals attraction between two characters, prescribing emotions already visible on screen. Such films seem unwilling to trust either their images or their audience. Gabriel Lerman, the festival’s other co-artistic director, called Kindik ‘a genuine find’. That enthusiasm sits uneasily beside a film so dependent on announcing what it has not built. A festival of this standing should demand more from its International Competition than the ability to declare an intention.

A professora de francês received the Special Jury Prize and Best Actress for Passô. I also served on the jury that awarded it the FIPRESCI Prize. Neither recognition obliges me to defend the competition as a whole. I was a guest, genuinely welcomed, and nobody demanded silence. Yet gratitude can make a guest reluctant to criticise. Thanking those who open their doors does not oblige us to praise their house. Nor does criticising it require us to burn it down.

Juan Carlos Lemus Polanía
© FIPRESCI 2026

Members Area
FIPRESCI © 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Newsletter

Signup for news from FIPRESCI every 1st of the month

Please wait...

Thank you for sign up!