Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Viva Carmen! Trapped by Beauty

Viva Carmen! Trapped by Beauty

Armenian film critic Artavazd Yeghiazaryan examines Sébastien Laudenbach’s Viva Carmen! at SCHLiNGEL 2026, exploring how the film’s extraordinary visual imagination struggles against the narrative constraints of Bizet’s familiar tragedy.

The 31st SCHLiNGEL International Film Festival for Children and Young Audiences in Chemnitz presented a particularly rich selection of animated features this year, showcasing the remarkable diversity of contemporary animation. Among the highlights was Louis Clichy’s Iron Boy, which emerged as one of the festival’s biggest winners, taking home three awards, including the FIPRESCI Prize, the Best Animated Feature Film Award and the Club of Festivals Junior Award.

But Iron Boy was far from the only French animated production worth discussing. Another standout was Sébastien Laudenbach’s visually extravagant Viva Carmen!, a striking reimagining of Bizet’s famous opera that demonstrates both the extraordinary possibilities and the narrative challenges of animated storytelling.

It is difficult to mistake French animator Sébastien Laudenbach’s films for anyone else’s. His distinctive visual language is built on a sense of deliberate incompleteness: outlines are often interrupted, colours spill beyond their boundaries, and characters sometimes consist of just a few brushstrokes. Yet there is an astonishing vitality in this economy of means. Laudenbach’s drawings seem to come into existence before our very eyes, constantly changing shape and direction.

The full potential of this style was revealed in the 2023 animated feature Chicken for Linda!, which Laudenbach co-directed with Chiara Malta. Winner of the top prize at the Annecy International Animation Film Festival and a French César Award, the film owed only half its dazzling success to its animation. The other half was its wonderful story, in which the poetry of a children’s tale found its place within the most down-to-earth domestic situation: a little girl simply wanted her mother to cook her some chicken. This modest wish gave rise to an entire adventure, with room for loss, maternal love, social issues and genuine cinematic magic.

In his new film, Viva Carmen!, Laudenbach’s visual world has become even more lavish. And no wonder: 19th-century Spain, with its sunshine, narrow streets, colourful markets, dances and passions, seems tailor-made for his palette and fluid sense of movement. The streets of Seville come alive in extraordinary combinations of orange, red and purple, while the interplay of light and shadow transforms every scene into a painting in its own right. Laudenbach seems to have finally freed himself from every limitation of the animated image.

But while the story and image developed hand in hand in Chicken for Linda!, this time the director faces a much more complicated challenge. Georges Bizet’s famous Carmen already comes with established characters, a familiar dramatic structure and an inevitable tragic ending. And however free and unpredictable Laudenbach’s animation may be, the well-known plot inevitably places certain limits on that freedom.

The director attempts to solve this problem by changing the point of view. Carmen and Don José’s ill-fated romance is now seen through the eyes of children living on the streets of Seville. The new protagonist, an orphan boy named Salvador, learns that Carmen’s life is in danger and sets out with his friends to prevent the tragedy. This device allows Laudenbach to turn a brutal story of adult passion and jealousy into something of a children’s adventure, making it more accessible to younger audiences.

At the same time, Laudenbach enriches the classical narrative with themes that resonate more strongly with contemporary sensibilities. Here, Carmen is not merely a femme fatale, but a woman defending her freedom and her right to make her own choices. Themes of female solidarity, violence and personal freedom lend the story a distinctly modern dimension. Yet these additions do not always come together organically. The children’s adventure, the familiar tragedy and the social commentary sometimes seem to compete with one another, preventing the narrative from achieving the lightness and spontaneity that made even the most improbable moments of Chicken for Linda! feel so natural.

The result is a somewhat paradoxical film. Laudenbach has created his most sumptuous, perhaps even his most beautiful animated world, in which practically every frame could be printed, framed and hung on a wall. Yet alongside this visual perfection, the story sometimes feels overly constructed and artificial. And while in his previous film poetry emerged from the most ordinary aspects of life, here there seems to be so much poetry that there is hardly any room left for life itself.

Viva Carmen! is a gorgeous film to look at, but not always a convincing story to believe in. And perhaps this is one of those rare occasions when Laudenbach’s boundless imagination is somewhat constrained by the sheer familiarity of the story he has chosen to tell.

Artavazd Yeghiazaryan
© FIPRESCI 2026

Members Area
FIPRESCI © 2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Newsletter

Signup for news from FIPRESCI every 1st of the month

Please wait...

Thank you for sign up!